The Lahore Ahmadiyya Movement Blog

@ Mohammed Iqbal sahib,

Yes brother there were people living in Qadian and later in Rabwah who did NOT believe QK2 Mirza Mehmud Ahmad was "Musleh Mahud". Prominent among them were their scholars, translators of Holy Quran, such as Malik Ghulam Fareed sahib, Maulvi Sher Ali sahib, and Abdul Manan Omar sahib. There were others too. These people had the same situation as Sahaba Akram of Holy Prophet Muhammad SAWS, who worked in the offices of administration of Yazeed bin Muawiyah (also called 'Yazeed-e-Paleed' by HMGA). I am sure there must be people even now among Qadianis who do NOT hold belief that QK2 was "Musleh Mahud". 

Dear Saad sahib: People are free to contribute different opinions here, within limits of decent language and proper behaviour. Being the Lahore Ahmadiyya blog does not mean that only Lahore Ahmadiyya views may be expressed here. It means that I, as admin, and my like-minded friends will answer questions about the LAM, and respond to objections against it, that anyone may raise here.

@Rashid Jahangiri sahib

Dr. Khalid Omar sb is not a reliable source, let me give you an example, according to you on this forum Khalid sb said the following:

"Mirza Tahir Ahmad went over the plan in which operation was to be conducted by Qadiani students, in which they were to wear turbans (like worn by Qadiani Khalifa 3,4, 5) carry 303 rifles, and containers of gasoline (patrol), run on two sides of street in famous market Anarkali Bazaar, Lahore and torch the bazaar"

Now a large number of my family members have gone to UET including my father and a few have even been heads of their respective departments there. Not one of my relatives can recall this event and not one of them has heard of this plan from any second hand source. Now, what I have heard from them again and again, was that the khalifas would always discourage Ahmadis from playing an active part in the political scene etc. Hudhur also met with prominent Ahmadi student leaders to discourage but many did not take heed including my uncle but backed out a little.

So Khalid sahib has no crediblity in my eyes.

——————————————————————————————————————

Now on to Hadhrat Maulvi Sher Ali ra, Khalid sbs mother was not his only child. He had another daughter, and 2 sons from my memory. One of the sons was a doctor and my mother just met his daughter at the Canadian Jalsa and she is a very pious and devout Ahmadi. My aunts father who every one called Mian sb lived on the family's Zameen in Burewala always swore that only reasoned he was distanced from Khilafat was that he at the time was hurt by harsh punishment of Mannan sb and he blamed various 'shrarti' or trouble makers in the Jamaat for his rift and even Mannan sbs rift. He also talked aout Maulvi sb legacy kept him from fully disconnecting and joining the Lahore group Another daughter of Maulvi Sb was married to who was either married to Chaudhry Fateh Muhammad Sial or his son would also attest to Maulvi sbs loyalty to Jamaat and her descendants are very active in Jammat.

——————————————————————————————————————

Hadhrat Malik Ghulam Farid's ra Family is all Ahmadi as far as I know, which makes your statement illogical, Malik sb a hypocrite if it is true (naoozubillah), plus being narrated by Khalid Omar sb  its unreliable to begin with and look at what I found on Malik family:

"A special favour by Mirza Nasir to the family of Abdul Mannan Omar: Bibi Amtul Rahman (deceased) was like a sister to my mother and considered my mother like an elders sister.  Once, a Rabwah woman met Bibi in a wedding and Bibi asked this woman to convey a special message to her elder sister.  The message was: ‘Recently, I was very worried about a match for my daughter as I did not want her to be married among non-Ahmadis (Muslims) nor among Paighamis (Lahori Ahmadis).  Allah had mercy on us and Mirza Nasir, out of his great favour and kindness, arranged a match for her with the son of Malik Ghulam Fareed.  With the grace of God, she is married now.  Mirza Nasir has bestowed a special favour on us.  Please convey this message to my elder sister.’  My mother told this story to me many times, wsalam, Malik Safiullah Khan, Toronto, Canada.”

Interesting Note: Mannan sb never did bait to any Lahori Emir and if he was a Lahori he was never made the Emir of the Lahore Jamaat even though he represented the Lahoris in th NA.

——————————————————————————————————————

I cannot say anything about Hadhrat Mufti Muhammad Sadiq's son, as I dont no much if anything about him